COIT20262 Advanced Network Security - Assignment 2
COIT20262 Advanced Network Security - Assignment 2
Attempt all questions.
Submit the following on Moodle:
- Answers: A Microsoft Word document containing answers to the questions.
- certificate.pem : see Question 4.
- https.pcap : see Question 4.
This is an individual assignment, and it is expected students answer the questions themselves. Discussion of approaches to solving questions is allowed (and encouraged), however each student should develop and write-up their own answers. See CQUniversity resources on Referencing and Plagiarism Guidelines for this assignment include:
- Do not exchange files (reports, captures, diagrams) with other students.
- Complete tasks with virtnet yourself
- do not use results from another student.
- Draw your own diagrams. Do not use diagrams from other sources (Internet, textbooks) or from other students.
- Write your own explanations. In some cases, students may arrive at the same numerical answer, however their explanation of the answer should always be their own.
- Do not copy text from websites or textbooks. During research you should read and understand what others have written, and then write in your own words.
Question 1. HTTPS and Certificates
For this question you must use virtnet to study HTTPS and certificates. This assumes you have already setup and are familiar with virtnet. See Moodle and tutorial instructions for information on setting up and using virtnet, deploying the website, and testing the website.
Your task is to setup a web server that supports HTTPS. The tasks and sub-questions are grouped into multiple phases.
Phase 1: Setup Topology
1. Create topology 5 in virtnet.
2. Deploy the MyUni demo website, with node3 being the real web server.
3. Change the domain name from by editing the /etc/hosts file on node1.
Phase 2: Certificate Signing Request
You will need to use the files made available to you for download from Assignment 1.
1. Using [StudentID]-keypair.pem you must create a Certificate Signing Request called [StudentID]-csr.pem. The CSR must contain these field values:
• State: state of your campus
• Locality: city of your campus
• Organisation Name: your full name
• Common Name
• Email address: your @cqumail address
• Other field values must be selected appropriately.
Phase 3: Certificate from CA
Send your Certificate Signing Request file to your Certificate Authority. The method of contacting your CA will be published on Moodle. You will be issued with a certificate called [StudentID]-cert.pem from CA (or in the case of an error, a response indicating the CSR is not valid).
Note that there may be a delay of up to 24 hours during weekdays (and 48 hours over the weekend) for the CA to respond to your CSR. Further details of the process can be found on Moodle.
Phase 3: HTTPs Configuration
1. Configure Apache web server on node3 to use HTTPS. Remember the domain name must be where [StudentID] is replace with your actual student ID.
2. Load the CA certificate into the client on node1. The CA certificate can be downloaded from Moodle.
Phase 4: Testing
1. Start capturing on node2 using tcpdump.
2. On node1, use lynx to visit and login to view some grades.
3. Exit lynx.
4. Stop the capturing and save the file as [StudentID]-https.pcap.
When capturing, make sure you capture a full HTTPS session, and avoiding capturing multiple sessions.
Phase 5: Analysis
(a) Add the CSR [StudentID]-csr.pem to [StudentID]-files.zip.
(b) Add the issued certificate [StudentID]-cert.pem to [StudentID]-files.zip.
(c) Add the packet capture [StudentID]-https.pcap to [StudentID]-files.zip.
(d) Based on your certificate and the capture, write answers to the following questions in
the table. When giving algorithms, you may use the abbreviation but must accurately identify the variant. For example, AES128 is different from AES256, and SHA256 is different from SHA512.
In phase 3 you sent your CSR to the CA, who responded with your issued certificate. Discuss the security issues with this process of sending the CSR to CA and receiving the certificate back using the communication methods used in this assignment. How could an attacker take advantage of this process to perform an attack?
Question 2. Authentication and Access Control
This question uses the same nodes as Question 1.
You need to configure the server (node3) to allow multiple different users to access it. These users will be web developers, creating and testing web content.
Phase 1: Create Users and Groups
On node3, add three (3) new users.
You will use the last three digits of your student ID in each of the usernames. For example, with the student ID 12345678, the last three digits are 8, 7 and 6. The users are:
For the example student ID 12345678, the three usernames will be web18, web27 and web36. The passwords are exactly as given in the table. In the following replace web1X with your allocated username, and so on.
Create a new group called webdev, and add all three new users to that group.
Phase 2: Permissions
The three web developers will work on files in the directory:
• var/www/html/test/ (owned by webdev group and web1X)
There are currently the following files/sub-directories:
• File: /var/www/html/test/index.html (owned by web1X)
• File: /var/www/html/test/about.html (owned by web2Y)
• Directory: /var/www/html/test/hidden/ (owned by web3Z)
• File: /var/www/html/test/hidden/new.html (owned by web3Z)
• File: /var/www/html/test/hidden/mine.html (owned by web3Z)
Create the test directory and all files and sub-directories within it. For the files add some content (e.g. some plain text; it doesn’t have to be a real HTML page).
The access control requirements are:
• All files and directories within test/ have webdev as the group owner.
• The index and about pages are publicly accessible web pages. The about page can be edited by any of the web developers; but the index page can only be edited by web1X.
• The hidden directory and files within it are not accessible by the public (i.e. via a web browser). All of the web developers can view and edit the files, except for mine.html, which is only viewable by web3Z.
Phase 3: Testing
Test that the users and permissions work as expected. That is, login as the different files and try to access the files.
To demonstrate that the users and permissions are correctly setup, do the following on node3:
1. Copy /etc/passwd to /home/network/[StudentID]-passwd.txt
2. Copy /etc/shadow to /home/network/[StudentID]-shadow.txt
3. Copy /etc/group to /home/network/[StudentID]-group.txt
4. Perform the following operation (when logged in as network user):
sudo ls -lRa /var/www/html/test/ > /home/network/[StudentID]-permissions.txt
This command should produce a file called [StudentID]-permissions.txt in the network user home directory which contains a long listing of all files in the test/ directory, showing permissions. Note the first option is the letter l, which is short for long listing, not the number
Phase 4: Analysis
(a) Add [StudentID]-passwd.txt to [StudentID]-files.zip.
(b) Add [StudentID]-shadow.txt to [StudentID]-files.zip .
(c) Add [StudentID]-group.txt to [StudentID]-files.zip.
(d) Add [StudentID]-permissions.txt to [StudentID]-files.zip.
(e) Discuss the security and convenience issues of the three different passwords selected
by the web developers.
(f) Assume that as administrator of node3, you have software that checks passwords selected by users when their account is first created. That software can allow the password or reject the password (forcing the users to select a different password). Explain what checks the software should perform to improve the chance that a user selects a good password.
(g) In Linux, explain how passwords are stored. Your answer must refer to the files you submitted, using the information from one web developer as an example. You must refer to the specific information and algorithms used.
Question 3. Firewalls and iptables
In this question you will use iptables and virtnet to create a firewall on node2 of the topology used in the previous questions. node1 is considered external and node3 is internal. Although there are only 3 machines in the topology, when creating your rules you must assume there will be more than that. For example, while there is only 1 internal subnet, there may be more than 2 internal nodes on that subnet (you don’t have to create additional nodes in virtnet; just design the rules assuming they are there).
Phase 1: Change SSH Server Port
SSH servers by default use port 22. However, the port can be changed by editing the SSH server configuration file: /etc/ssh/sshd_config. For the change take effect, the SSH server needs to be restarted with:
sudo systemctl restart sshd
Once the SSH server port has changed, then SSH clients can specify the port using the -p option, e.g.
Change the SSH server port on node3 to 22XY where XY is the last two digits of your student ID. For example, with the student ID 12345678, the port would be 2278.
Phase 2: Setup the Firewall
You need to setup an iptables based firewall on node2. The firewall must use SPI and have a default policy of DROP. Configure the firewall to implement the following security policy.
• All external nodes can access the HTTPS web server on node3.
• No external nodes can use HTTP to access the web server on node3.
• node1 is the only external node that can access the SSH server on node3.
• All internal nodes can access HTTP, HTTPS, SSH servers on any external node.
• node3 is allowed to ping external nodes, but no other internal node can ping out, and no external node can ping in.
Remember that while node1 is the only external node, and node3 is the only internal node, you must write your firewall rules assuming there are other internal/external nodes, on potentially different subnets.
Phase 3: Test the Firewall and Servers
You should extensively test your firewall and servers to ensure the security policies (of the firewall and file access control) are implemented correctly. To test the firewall you can use wget for HTTP/HTTPS, ssh for SSH and netcat for other services. For example, you can use netcat in server mode to start a server on a chosen port, and then use netcat in client mode to attempt to connect to that server (see Assignment 1 instructions for netcat examples).
To demonstrate that your firewall and servers are working correctly, take screenshots of the following scenarios. Each screenshot must clearly show only node1 and must be taken with the in-built VirtualBox screenshot tool (View menu -- Take Screenshot).
Phase 4: Save the Rules
Once you have determined the firewall is correct, save the rules to a file using:
sudo iptables-save -c > [StudentID]-iptables.txt
This should create the file [StudentID]-iptables.txt which contains a summary of your rules.
Phase 5: Analysis
You must include the screenshots in your report – do not submit the screenshot files separately.
(a) Include [StudentID]-screenshot1.png in your report.
(b) Include [StudentID]-screenshot2.png in your report.
(c) Include [StudentID]-screenshot3.png in your report.
(d) Include [StudentID]-screenshot4.png in your report.
(e) Add [StudentID]-iptables.txt to [StudentID]-files.zip.
(f) If an internal SSH server is accessible to multiple external users, then discuss how an attacker without an account on the SSH server attempt to gain access. As the SSH server administrator, discuss countermeasures you may use, and for those countermeasures, any limitations or negative side-effects.
(g) You changed the port of the SSH server from the default value to another value. Discuss the security and convenience issues of changing the port from it’s default value.
(h) Explain how an external attacker could attempt to determine what servers are accessible on the internal network, and which servers are blocked by the firewall.
Question 4. Internet Privacy
Encryption is commonly used to provide data confidentiality in the Internet: when two hosts communicate, other entities in the path between the two hosts cannot read the data being sent. However encryption on its own does not privacy of who is communicating. Although the other entities cannot read the data, they can determine which two hosts are communicating.
Assume you want to have privacy protection while web browsing. Normally, when your client computer sends a HTTP GET request to a web server, the IP address of both your client computer (C) and the web server (S) are included in the IP header of the packet. Any intermediate node on the path between client and server in the Internet can see the values of C and S, thereby learning who is communicating.
Three common techniques for privacy protection, i.e. hiding both values of C and S from intermediate nodes, in the Internet are:
• Web proxies
(a) Explain how a web proxy works. Your explanation should include what a user needs to do when using a web proxy, what security it provides, and what are the security and convenience limitations.
(b) Explain the benefits and limitations of a user gains by using a VPN, compared to a web proxy.
(c) What are the security and convenience weaknesses of a home user using a VPN for private browsing.